Publication Ethics

Our Commitment to Publication Ethics

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) is a peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal published by Sinar Mentari Sundara. This statement clarifies the ethical responsibilities of all parties involved in the publication process, including authors, the Editor-in-Chief, Editorial Board members, peer reviewers, and the publisher.

This statement is based on the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Core Practices and internationally recognized standards of ethical scholarly publishing. AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) is committed to ensuring transparency, fairness, accountability, and research integrity throughout the editorial and publication process.

QUICK NAVIGATION

Explore Our Ethical Policies

Select a policy below to navigate directly to its section.

01. Ethical Guideline for Journal Publication

The publication of scholarly articles in AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) contributes to the development of a credible and reliable scientific knowledge network. As a peer-reviewed journal, AIR supports the dissemination of original research addressing artificial intelligence, environmental innovation, sustainability, climate resilience, and interdisciplinary technological developments. Peer-reviewed publications reflect the scientific contributions of researchers and their affiliated institutions. Therefore, the integrity of the publication process depends on the ethical conduct of authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher.

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) requires all participants to uphold the principles of originality, objectivity, transparency, confidentiality, and accountability. Research findings must be reported accurately, supported by appropriate evidence, and presented without fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, or misleading interpretation. All parties involved in scholarly publishing are expected to follow recognized ethical standards to preserve the credibility and reliability of the academic record.

02. Generative AI Policies

In response to the rapid development and increasing adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies in academic research and scholarly publishing,  AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) is committed to promoting the responsible, transparent, and ethical use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI). Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to comply with AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) Generative AI policies in addition to the publication ethics outlined on this page.

AI-assisted technologies may support manuscript preparation, language improvement, coding, research organization, and other scholarly activities. However, these technologies must not replace independent scientific judgment or human responsibility. Authors remain fully accountable for the originality, accuracy, validity, and integrity of their manuscripts. Any substantive use of Generative AI must be appropriately disclosed in accordance with the journal's established policy. Generative AI systems must not be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot assume responsibility for scholarly contributions. The complete policy concerning the responsible use of Generative AI is available on the journal's Generative AI Policies page.

View Complete Generative AI Policies ↗

03. Conflict of Interest

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) is committed to maintaining transparency, impartiality, and objectivity throughout the scholarly publication process. Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose any financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, research findings, peer-review assessments, or editorial decisions.

Disclosure Requirements

Authors must declare relevant conflicts of interest when submitting manuscripts, including financial support, employment relationships, consultancy arrangements, institutional affiliations, and other circumstances that may affect the interpretation of their research. Reviewers and editors must disclose potential conflicts of interest and withdraw from the evaluation or decision-making process when their independence or objectivity could be compromised.

Editorial Handling

All disclosed conflicts of interest will be assessed by the editorial team. Appropriate measures may include assigning an independent editor, appointing alternative reviewers, or implementing other safeguards to ensure a fair and unbiased review process. AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) expects all participants to disclose relevant conflicts honestly and promptly to maintain public trust in scholarly communication.

04. Allegations of Research Misconduct

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) is committed to preserving the integrity of scientific research and the scholarly publication record. Allegations of research misconduct, including plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, manipulated research findings, and other unethical practices, will be treated seriously and evaluated through fair, impartial, and confidential procedures.

How Allegations Are Handled

01. Initial Assessment

The responsible editor evaluates the allegation and available supporting evidence to determine whether further examination or investigation is necessary.

02. Investigation

Relevant documentation, manuscripts, research data, and other supporting materials may be examined. Authors or other individuals involved may be contacted to provide clarification, explanations, or additional evidence.

03. Editorial Decision

The editorial team objectively evaluates the findings and determines appropriate action based on the available evidence, the seriousness of the concern, and applicable publication ethics standards.

04. Corrective Action

When research misconduct is substantiated, appropriate measures may include manuscript rejection, publication of a correction, expression of concern, article retraction, or notification of relevant academic institutions or research organizations.

Confidentiality and Fairness

All allegations will be handled with appropriate confidentiality, impartiality, and respect for the rights of the individuals involved.  AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) does not consider allegations alone sufficient evidence of misconduct. Editorial decisions must be supported by verifiable evidence and relevant ethical guidelines, including those recommended by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Reporting Suspected Misconduct

Concerns regarding suspected research misconduct may be submitted to the AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) editorial office with a clear explanation of the issue and any relevant supporting evidence.

Contact the Editorial Office: air@sundarapublishing.com

05. Duties of Authors Criteria

1. Reporting Standards

Authors of original research must present an accurate and objective account of the research conducted, including its methodology, results, and scientific significance. Research data must be reported truthfully, and manuscripts should provide sufficient methodological detail and references to allow other researchers to evaluate or reproduce the study. Fabricated, falsified, or knowingly misleading statements constitute unethical research behavior and are unacceptable.

2. Data Access and Retention

Authors may be requested to provide relevant research data for editorial examination and should be prepared to make supporting data available when reasonably practicable and ethically appropriate. Research data should be retained for a reasonable period following publication. Any restrictions involving confidentiality, privacy, institutional agreements, or legal requirements must be respected.

3. Originality and Plagiarism

Authors must ensure that submitted manuscripts represent original scholarly work. Any ideas, data, figures, methods, or text derived from other sources must be appropriately acknowledged through accurate citation or quotation. Plagiarism, unattributed copying, and misleading representation of previously published work are unacceptable.

4. Multiple, Redundant or Concurrent Publication

Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals or publish substantially identical research findings in more than one primary publication without legitimate justification and appropriate disclosure. Duplicate or redundant publication that misrepresents the originality of research is considered unethical publishing behavior.

5. Acknowledgment of Sources

Authors must appropriately acknowledge the contributions and publications of other researchers. Sources that have substantially influenced the development, methodology, interpretation, or conclusions of the study must be cited accurately. References must be relevant, reliable, and verifiable.

6. Authorship of the Paper

Authorship must be limited to individuals who have made substantial contributions to the conception, design, implementation, analysis, or interpretation of the research. All individuals who qualify for authorship should be included as co-authors, while contributions that do not meet authorship criteria should be appropriately acknowledged. The corresponding author must ensure that all listed authors have reviewed and approved the final manuscript and agreed to its submission for publication.

7. Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest

Authors must disclose relevant financial support, institutional relationships, professional interests, or other circumstances that could influence the research findings or their interpretation. All sources of research funding and significant potential conflicts of interest must be transparently reported.

8. Fundamental Errors in Published Works

When authors discover significant errors or inaccuracies in their published research, they must promptly notify the journal editor or publisher and cooperate in implementing appropriate corrective action, including corrections or retractions when justified.

06. Duties of Editors

1. Fair Play and Editorial Independence

Editors must evaluate submitted manuscripts based exclusively on academic merit, originality, methodological quality, scientific validity, and relevance to the journal's focus and scope. Editorial decisions must not be influenced by an author's nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, religious beliefs, political views, or other personal characteristics unrelated to scholarly quality. The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for maintaining editorial independence and overseeing decisions concerning manuscript acceptance, rejection, revision, and publication.

2. Confidentiality

Editors and editorial staff must maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts. Information concerning submissions may only be disclosed to individuals appropriately involved in the editorial process, including corresponding authors, reviewers, potential reviewers, editorial advisers, and the publisher when necessary.

3. Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest

Editors and Editorial Board members must not use unpublished information obtained through manuscript submissions for personal research or professional advantage without the authors' explicit permission. Editors must withdraw from handling manuscripts when conflicts of interest arise from financial, professional, collaborative, competitive, or personal relationships with the authors or associated institutions.

4. Publication Decisions

Editors are responsible for determining which submitted manuscripts are suitable for publication. Decisions must be guided by the journal's editorial policies, peer-review evaluations, academic quality standards, and relevant legal requirements concerning plagiarism, copyright, and research integrity. Editors may consult other Editorial Board members or reviewers when making publication decisions.

5. Involvement and Cooperation in Investigations

Editors must respond appropriately to credible ethical complaints involving submitted manuscripts or published articles. When necessary, editors will examine the available evidence, communicate with relevant authors or institutions, and determine suitable corrective action. Where ethical concerns are substantiated, the journal may publish a correction, retraction, expression of concern, or other editorial notice to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

07. Duties of Reviewers

1. Contribution to Editorial Decisions

Peer review supports editorial decision-making by providing independent evaluations of manuscript quality, originality, methodological rigor, scientific validity, and relevance to the journal's scope. Constructive reviewer feedback also helps authors improve the clarity and quality of their research.

2. Promptness

Reviewers who consider themselves insufficiently qualified to evaluate a manuscript or are unable to complete the review within the required period must promptly notify the responsible editor and decline the assignment when appropriate.

3. Confidentiality

Manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not distribute, disclose, or discuss submitted manuscripts with unauthorized individuals without permission from the editor.

4. Standards of Objectivity

Reviews must be conducted impartially and professionally. Personal criticism, discriminatory remarks, or unsupported judgments are unacceptable. Reviewers should provide clear, constructive, and evidence-based assessments to support editorial decisions and manuscript improvement.

5. Acknowledgment of Sources

Reviewers should identify relevant scholarly publications that have not been appropriately acknowledged by the authors. Any substantial similarity or overlap between the submitted manuscript and previously published research should be reported to the editor with supporting information. Reviewers should also highlight methodological weaknesses, unsupported conclusions, and concerns regarding the validity or reproducibility of research findings.

6. Disclosure and Conflict of Interest

Confidential information and unpublished ideas obtained during peer review must not be used for personal, academic, or commercial advantage. Reviewers must decline assignments when financial, professional, institutional, collaborative, competitive, or personal relationships could compromise their impartiality.

08. Duties of the Publisher (Sinar Mentari Sundara)

1. Commitment to Ethical Oversight

Sinar Mentari Sundara, as the publisher of AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR), is committed to supporting responsible scholarly publishing practices and maintaining internationally recognized standards of publication ethics. The publisher supports the implementation of transparent editorial policies, ethical peer-review procedures, and appropriate measures to address research integrity concerns.

2. Safeguarding the Academic Record

Sinar Mentari Sundara supports the preservation of the integrity and reliability of published scholarly content. The publisher cooperates with the journal's editorial team in addressing ethical concerns, correcting publication errors, and implementing retractions or other appropriate measures when necessary. Commercial interests, advertising arrangements, or other external considerations must not improperly influence editorial decisions.

3. Editorial Independence

Sinar Mentari Sundara recognizes and supports the editorial independence of  AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR).

The Editor-in-Chief and editorial team must be able to make publication decisions based on scientific merit, peer-review assessments, ethical requirements, and the journal's established editorial policies without inappropriate external interference.

09. Post-Publication Updates, Corrections, and Retractions

Scholarly discussion and continued scientific evaluation may reveal errors, omissions, methodological concerns, or potential ethical issues in published articles. When such concerns arise, AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) will evaluate the available evidence and determine whether additional examination or corrective action is necessary. Depending on the nature, seriousness, and implications of the findings, the journal may implement the following measures:

Correction

Publication of a formal correction notice when a verified error requires amendment without invalidating the main research findings.

Expression of Concern

Publication of a notice when serious concerns regarding an article remain unresolved while further assessment or investigation is ongoing.

Retraction

Withdrawal of an article from the valid scholarly record when substantial evidence demonstrates unreliable findings, serious ethical violations, or other circumstances warranting retraction.

Editorial Clarification

Publication of an explanatory statement when additional information is necessary to ensure accurate interpretation of the research.

Corrections, expressions of concern, and retraction notices should be clearly identified and linked to the affected articles whenever technically feasible. The original publication record should generally remain accessible with appropriate notices to maintain scholarly transparency, except where legal requirements or exceptional circumstances justify restricted access. AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) considers relevant COPE guidance when evaluating post-publication concerns and implementing corrective actions.

10. Digital Preservation and Archiving Policy

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) is committed to maintaining the integrity, accessibility, and long-term preservation of its published scholarly content. Digital preservation is essential for ensuring that scientific publications remain accessible to researchers, academic institutions, policymakers, and the wider scholarly community. The journal seeks to maintain appropriate digital archiving and backup procedures to support content preservation, data integrity, and recovery in the event of technical disruptions. Published articles and their bibliographic metadata are maintained through the journal's official publishing platform. Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) are assigned to eligible scholarly content to support persistent identification and reliable citation.

Formal participation in external digital preservation services, including the PKP Preservation Network (PKP PN), LOCKSS, or CLOCKSS, will be stated on the journal's official website when such arrangements have been established and verified.  AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) recognizes digital preservation as an ongoing responsibility and supports continuous improvement of archival practices to safeguard the scholarly record for future generations.

INTERNATIONAL STANDARD

Ethical Reference

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – Core Practices

https://publicationethics.org/core-practices ↗
GET IN TOUCH

Editorial Office

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR)

Publisher: Sinar Mentari Sundara

AI, Innovation, and Resilience for the Environment Journal (AIR) | Publication Ethics and Research Integrity

↑ Back to Top